MoTradeSystems — Clarity, not certainty.

Strategy notes

Popular trading ideas, each tested on historical data with rules fixed in advance. A selection from 50+ pre-registered tests.

Each note tells you what the idea is, what was tested, on which data, and how to read the result. These are tests on historical data, not live trading.

How to read a note

Did not hold up as a rule
In the pre-registered test on historical data this rule did not hold up beyond chance. Good to know before you rely on it.
Useful only as a portfolio building block
Not a signal on its own. In the test it helped as part of a portfolio, for example on the risk side.
Test not finished
No result yet. The note says what is still open.

The notes

Market context and filters

Market-regime filter for direction

Useful only as a portfolio building block

A risk-on / risk-off read is assumed to time entries better.

What was tested
Whether “risk-on / risk-off” times entries better.
Data
16 years of futures + equities
Where you will meet this idea
Risk-on / risk-off, the framing behind most macro commentary.

It helps with risk, not with timing.

Volume and liquidity zones as orientation

Useful only as a portfolio building block

Areas of heavy and of thin traded volume are assumed to improve entries.

What was tested
Whether “clear paths” and high-volume zones improve entries.
Data
16 years of Nasdaq futures
Where you will meet this idea
Volume profile and liquidity zones, presented as a map of where price "has to" go.

Good as context, not as a trigger.

Defensive stocks in nervous phases

Useful only as a portfolio building block

Solid, quiet companies are assumed to lead when the market is under stress.

What was tested
Whether solid and quiet stocks lead during stress.
Data
~25 years of US equities
Where you will meet this idea
The flight to defensives, a common theme in market-stress commentary.

Stacking many signals (“confluence”)

Did not hold up as a rule

More filters pointing the same way are assumed to produce better trades.

What was tested
Whether more filters mean a better hit rate.
Data
~25 years of US equities
Where you will meet this idea
The premise behind many "confluence" indicators offered on chart platforms.

Stacking does not improve the hit rate.

Mixing several genuine building blocks (diversification)

Useful only as a portfolio building block

Uncorrelated sources of return are assumed to work better together than alone.

What was tested
Whether uncorrelated sources produce a better ratio in combination.
Data
Equities + bonds + overnight
Where you will meet this idea
Diversification, an idea that runs from academic finance all the way to retail.

Intraday futures

Breakout above the opening range

Did not hold up as a rule

A move out of the first range of the session is assumed to set the direction for the day.

What was tested
Whether a morning breakout carries the rest of the day.
Data
16 years of Nasdaq futures
Where you will meet this idea
The setup most day-trading courses open with.

Buying the pullback in a trend

Did not hold up as a rule

A dip inside an existing trend is assumed to be a cheaper entry in the same direction.

What was tested
Whether “the dip” can be traded within a trend.
Data
16 years of Nasdaq futures
Where you will meet this idea
The "buy the pullback in a trend" rule, a frequent topic in technical-analysis primers.

The European session carries into the US open

Did not hold up as a rule

The direction set overnight is assumed to continue after the US open.

What was tested
Whether the overnight direction persists.
Data
16 years of Nasdaq futures
Where you will meet this idea
The "follow the overnight session" argument you hear ahead of the US open.

Closing-hour drift

Did not hold up as a rule

The final hour of the session is assumed to have a direction of its own.

What was tested
Whether the last trading hour has a direction.
Data
16 years of Nasdaq futures
Where you will meet this idea
"Power hour", the late-session drift intraday chat rooms trade around.

The opening gap “fills itself”

Did not hold up as a rule

A price gap at the open is assumed to close again during the day.

What was tested
Whether morning price gaps close again.
Data
16 years of Nasdaq futures
Where you will meet this idea
"Gaps always fill", a frequent rule in retail trading.

Reversion to the daily average (VWAP)

Did not hold up as a rule

Price is assumed to snap back towards the volume-weighted average of the day.

What was tested
Whether prices spring back to the middle of the day.
Data
16 years of Nasdaq futures
Where you will meet this idea
VWAP mean reversion, often shown on intraday charts.

The apparent hit turned out to be a measurement error.

Trading around economic releases

Did not hold up as a rule

Scheduled macro releases are assumed to give a tradable direction.

What was tested
Whether direction can be traded ahead of rate decisions or labour-market data.
Data
16 years of Nasdaq futures
Where you will meet this idea
The "trade the news" school: position ahead of the Fed or the jobs report.

A well-known small pattern ahead of rate decisions is real, but too small to stand on its own. It stays a calendar note.

Classic price strategies for stocks

“Buy the losers, sell the winners” (mean reversion)

Did not hold up as a rule

Recent losers are assumed to bounce back and recent winners to fall behind.

What was tested
Whether short-term overreactions can be traded on the way back.
Data
~18 years of US equities
Where you will meet this idea
The "it has fallen, so it must come back" argument, turned into a rule.

“Ride the trend” (momentum)

Did not hold up as a rule

Whatever went up recently is assumed to keep going up.

What was tested
Whether recent winners keep on winning.
Data
~18 years of US equities
Where you will meet this idea
The default setting of most trend-following courses: ride your winners.

“Buy the strong sectors” (sector trend)

Did not hold up as a rule

The leading industries are assumed to stay in front.

What was tested
Whether leading sectors stay ahead.
Data
~18 years of US equities
Where you will meet this idea
Sector-rotation commentary and the "stay in the strongest sector" school.

“Prefer the solid companies” (quality)

Did not hold up as a rule

Companies with strong balance sheets are assumed to outperform weak ones.

What was tested
Whether balance-sheet strength beats balance-sheet weakness.
Data
~25 years of US equities
Where you will meet this idea
Quality investing, a respected idea and the basis of many factor funds.

Other building blocks

Broad trend following (long only)

Did not hold up as a rule

A simple trend rule is assumed to carry across many markets at once.

What was tested
Whether simple trend following holds up across markets.
Data
Futures + ETFs, ~9 years
Where you will meet this idea
Common in managed-futures material and the "just follow the trend across markets" pitch.

Spreading across markets carried it, the signal did not.

Currency interest-rate differential (carry)

Did not hold up as a rule

High-yield currencies are assumed to pay more than low-yield ones, tested with a crisis-protection rule applied.

What was tested
Whether high-yield against low-yield currencies holds up with a crisis-protection rule.
Data
~20 years of FX rates
Where you will meet this idea
The carry trade, a staple of FX commentary, and a recurring headline after unwinds.

Timing bonds off the yield curve

Did not hold up as a rule

The steepness of the curve is assumed to time phases in bonds.

What was tested
Whether curve steepness times bond phases.
Data
~24 years of bond ETFs
Where you will meet this idea
Yield-curve timing, the bond version of "the chart tells you when".

Reaction to quarterly results (drift)

Test not finished

Prices are assumed to keep drifting in the direction of an earnings surprise.

What was tested
Whether prices drift on after earnings.
Data
US equities (several datasets)
Where you will meet this idea
Post-earnings drift, a well-documented anomaly in the academic literature.

Not cleanly testable with the data available to us.

The Treasury auction cycle

Did not hold up as a rule

Dealers forced to absorb supply around auctions are assumed to create a rhythm.

What was tested
Whether forced dealer buying around auctions creates a rhythm.
Data
~four years of 10-year Treasury futures
Where you will meet this idea
The auction-cycle argument you meet in fixed-income commentary.

Volume-zone breakout (“auction market”)

Did not hold up as a rule

A move out of the previous day's volume zone is assumed to run.

What was tested
Whether breakouts from the prior day's volume zone hold up.
Data
9 years of Nasdaq futures
Where you will meet this idea
Auction market theory, the framework behind most value-area and market-profile teaching.

Passive bond risk premium (duration)

Test not finished

A calmly sized, permanent duration position is assumed to harvest a genuine premium.

What was tested
Whether a quietly dosed duration position harvests a real premium.
Data
10-year Treasury futures
Where you will meet this idea
The "own duration, collect the premium" argument in bond-allocation debates.

Buying the dip in a bull market (equity index)

Test not finished

“Buy the dip” is assumed to work as long as the longer trend points up.

What was tested
Whether buying the dip only holds up in an uptrend.
Data
~20 years of a Nasdaq ETF
Where you will meet this idea
"Buy the dip, but only in a bull market", the rule that sounds too sensible to test.

Reaction to earnings guidance

Test not finished

Deviations from analyst expectations are assumed to keep working through the price.

What was tested
Whether deviations from analyst expectations drift on.
Data
US equities
Where you will meet this idea
Guidance surprises, the reason earnings previews focus on the outlook, not the quarter.

Needs data we currently do not have.

These 25 notes are a readable selection from 50+ pre-registered tests. Several further variants led to the same picture. The notes carry no performance figures.

These results are based on simulated or hypothetical performance results that have certain inherent limitations. Unlike the results shown in an actual performance record, these results do not represent actual trading. Also, because these trades have not actually been executed, these results may have under- or over-compensated for the impact, if any, of certain market factors, such as lack of liquidity. Simulated or hypothetical trading programs in general are also subject to the fact that they are designed with the benefit of hindsight. No representation is being made that any account will or is likely to achieve profits or losses similar to these being shown.

Trading futures and other leveraged products involves substantial risk of loss and is not suitable for all investors. Past performance is not indicative of future results. This content is for educational purposes only and is not investment advice.

For key levels in the Nasdaq 100, see the book: NAS100 Trading Playbook →

More pre-registered tests